Should you charge for returns in 2026? What the data says about return fees and holiday return windows
Disclosure: Cart Signal is published by Uassist.ME, which sells customer-support, order-ops and back-office staffing, so it has a commercial interest in this topic. No company named below paid for coverage. Vendor figures are labeled vendor-reported, and the year each figure covers is stated.
Short answer: Many merchants already do, but shoppers dislike it. In Loop's 2026 benchmark of more than 4,000 Shopify merchants, 65.2% charged a fee on at least some return outcomes, with an average fee of $9.04 (vendor-reported, Loop). A separate October 2026 reading of 4,908 Shopify refund policies by PageSpeed Matters, an ecommerce agency, found 40.8% mention a restocking fee or customer-paid return shipping; it measures policy wording, not fees charged, so the two figures aren't directly comparable (PageSpeed Matters, Oct 19, 2026). In a 2026 Morning Consult survey, three-quarters of adults said return fees are unreasonable (Morning Consult). If you charge, charge on specific outcomes, explain why, and make sure your support team can explain the policy before the holiday rush.
How many merchants charge return fees?
About two-thirds of the merchants in one large vendor dataset. Loop, which sells returns software, analyzed 23.4 million returns from more than 4,000 Shopify merchants worldwide that use its Returns Portal, covering Nov 1, 2024 to Oct 31, 2025. All figures below are vendor-reported and describe Loop's own customers, not all retailers (Loop, Retention Benchmarks 2026):
| Policy setting (Loop merchants) | Figure |
|---|---|
| Merchants charging fees on at least some return outcomes | 65.2% |
| Average fee charged on returns (normalized to USD) | $9.04 |
| Average window to request a refund | 39 days |
| Average window to request an exchange | 41 days |
| Merchants offering exchanges | 73.6% |
Loop describes fees as "becoming targeted, not universal." In other words, most of these merchants charge on some outcomes (such as a refund to the original payment method) rather than on every return. Loop's metrics exclude returns blocked before submission, such as final-sale items.
A different method gives a lower number. PageSpeed Matters, an ecommerce agency, read the refund policies of 4,908 Shopify stores that rank in Google (October 2026). 40.8% mention a restocking fee, customer-paid return shipping or both; 24.8% mention a restocking fee (median 20% among the 818 that state an amount) and 24.2% make the customer pay return shipping. Only 9.5% promise free returns. The study is a phrase-pattern reading: "A mention of a fee does not mean every return is charged" (PageSpeed Matters, Oct 19, 2026). The two datasets measure different things. Loop counts fee settings among its own customers, merchants who already use a returns portal; PageSpeed Matters reads public policy text across a broader set of stores. Neither tells you what share of shoppers actually pay a fee.
Why do retailers charge for returns?
Mostly because returns cost more to process and ship. In NRF and Happy Returns' 2025 Retail Returns Landscape, the top reasons retailers gave for charging for returns were (NRF, Oct 15, 2025):
- higher costs of operations to process returns (40%)
- higher carrier shipping costs (40%)
- economic uncertainty and the risk of tariffs (33%)
That report is trade-association research co-produced with Happy Returns, a UPS company that sells returns services. Its retailer survey covered 358 ecommerce professionals at large US merchants (over $500 million in revenue) across several categories, and its consumer survey covered 2,006 shoppers who had returned at least one online purchase in the past 12 months. These are 2025 figures; we found no 2026 edition.
The same report puts the scale of returns across the whole retail industry in 2025 at (NRF, Oct 15, 2025; full report: NRF):
- $849.9 billion in returns, or 15.8% of annual sales (retailer estimate)
- 19.3% of online sales returned
- 9% of all returns fraudulent
- 17% of holiday sales expected to be returned
How do shoppers feel about return fees?
Badly. Morning Consult's 2026 Holiday Season Retail Trends survey found that three-quarters of adults say return fees are unreasonable. It also found that half of Gen Z adults often order multiple sizes, colors or versions planning to return some, compared with 7% of Baby Boomers (Morning Consult, 2026). Morning Consult's public report page does not list the sample size or field dates. MediaPost, a secondary source, reports that the survey covered 1,301 U.S. adults and was conducted Sept. 25–27 (MediaPost).
A September 2026 survey from Blue Yonder, a supply-chain software vendor, found that 63% of 2,000 US consumers would not pay any fee to return a product, the highest of the five countries it surveyed. 44% said paying a fee is the most inconvenient part of a return (vendor survey of more than 5,000 consumers in five countries, including 2,000 in the US; Blue Yonder, PDF). In an Oct 27 blog post on the same survey, Blue Yonder says "82% of U.S. respondents would shop less often or stop shopping entirely at a retailer that limits their ability to return due to high return frequency" (Blue Yonder, Oct 27, 2026).
NRF's 2025 consumer survey points the same way. 82% of shoppers said free returns are a major consideration when buying, up from 76% the year before, and 76% said they are more likely to choose a return option that gives an instant refund or exchange. About 71% said they are less likely to shop with a retailer again after a poor returns experience (NRF, Oct 15, 2025).
Outside the US, the trend in German-speaking Europe runs toward free returns. A survey of 108 online retailers in Austria, Germany and Switzerland found that 60.6% now cover return shipping costs in full, up from 49.2% a year earlier (survey of 108 online retailers, mostly based in Germany, summer 2026; the page doesn't name who ran it; EU Retail Platform, Oct 8, 2026).
The tension is plain: fees cover a real cost, but they risk a customer who doesn't come back. That is why Loop's merchants tend to charge on some outcomes and keep exchanges free or cheaper.
What did Amazon change about holiday returns?
Amazon has made its extended holiday return window a standing annual rule. Amazon told sellers in an Oct 15, 2026 announcement on Seller Central (Amazon Seller Forums, Oct 15, 2026):
- Items bought on Amazon.com from Nov 1 to Dec 31, 2026 can be returned until Jan 31, 2027.
- Apple brand products have an earlier deadline of Jan 15, 2027.
- The window applies to all items sold on Amazon.com, whether the seller uses Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) or ships orders itself (FBM). Sellers don't need to do anything. Amazon says existing return and refund conditions remain unchanged.
- The post states: "This policy will apply every year."
PPC Land notes that a Nov 1 purchase gets up to 91 days to come back, which means Q4 sales can keep turning into returns until the end of January. Even if you don't sell on Amazon, many of your customers will shop there, and some will expect a similar holiday window from you.
For FBA sellers, Amazon also said on Oct 19, 2026: "You can now provide your own criteria for how we evaluate your Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) customer returns for resale." Amazon uses that input "as guidance during grading" (Amazon Seller Forums, News_Amazon, Oct 19, 2026).
What about TikTok Shop?
If you sell on TikTok Shop US, you may not get to charge for many returns. Its after-sales policy (dated Oct 21, 2026) makes the seller pay return shipping for every listed reason, including "No longer needed," when the customer uses TikTok's drop-off option; customers who arrange their own return shipping pay for it. Select qualified sellers can set a 30-, 45- or 90-day return window (14 days in some categories), but TikTok may override it in holiday or promotional periods and says sellers get at least 7 days' notice before it extends return windows. For BFCM 2026 it has: items sold from Nov 11, 2026 (16:00 PT) to Dec 31, 2026 (23:59 PT) can be returned until Feb 10, 2027, and the extension "will take precedence over seller-configured return window (if any)." Some categories, "like electronics and jewelry, may still follow their standard return rules," and auction orders aren't eligible (TikTok Shop BFCM Seller Campaign Guide, Oct 19, 2026). TikTok's after-sales policy gives sellers 4 business days to review a return request before TikTok "may automatically approve" it (2 business days for refund-only requests on items $100 or less) (TikTok Shop Seller University, Oct 21, 2026). TikTok's BFCM guide, dated two days earlier, gives shorter clocks for what it calls L2L sellers: 2 business days for a first review of a return and refund, 4 for a second review, and 2 for refund-only requests. It says its "standard aftersales review SLAs stay the same during BFCM" and that a missed SLA means the request "may be auto-approved in the buyer's favor" (TikTok Shop BFCM Seller Campaign Guide, Oct 19, 2026). TikTok doesn't explain the difference. Our advice: plan to the shorter deadline and check the one shown in Seller Center.
How should you decide on return fees and holiday windows?
This is our editorial checklist, not a benchmark. Work through it before November:
- Know your return cost per order. Add up return shipping, processing labor and lost resale value by category. A fee only makes sense if you know what it is meant to recover.
- Charge on outcomes, not on every return. Consider keeping exchanges and store credit free and charging only on refunds to the original payment method. That matches the "targeted, not universal" pattern in Loop's data. If you charge a return shipping fee and use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform in the US: from Oct 23, 2026, "return shipping fees will be taxed like any other shipping charge," on orders shipped to US addresses. If shipping is untaxed in a state, return shipping fees there stay untaxed. Shopify says merchants with a manual workaround should review it "to avoid double-counting tax." (Shopify Changelog, Sep 25, 2026)
- Decide your holiday window on purpose. Choose whether purchases from Nov 1 onward get a longer window, and pick a clear end date. Write that date down rather than "30 days after the holidays." On Shopify, you can set a different return window by market for specific collections, products or variants; "The shortest override wins," and final-sale items still can't be returned. Shopify's own example: a 14-day window for a "Holiday 2026" collection while the store default stays at 90 days. (Shopify Changelog, Sep 29, 2026)
- Watch for fraud and bracketing. Policies that allow multiple sizes or long windows also attract abuse. Agree in advance what your team can approve, deny or escalate.
- Put the policy everywhere customers look. Product pages, cart, order confirmation emails, your help center and your returns portal should all show the same fee and the same deadline.
- Plan January capacity. Returns tickets peak after the holidays. See How much will support tickets rise this holiday peak? for the staffing side.
What should your support team have ready?
Customers who dislike fees will contact support about them. These are our suggested macros, to adapt to your own policy:
- "Why am I being charged to return this?" State the fee, what it covers and the free alternative (for example, filling in your own amount: "Exchanges and store credit are free. A [your fee] fee applies only to refunds to your original payment method, to cover return shipping."). Our advice: if you use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform in the US, the fee a customer sees may now include tax, so say so in this macro.
- "What's your holiday return deadline?" Give the exact date, and say which purchase dates it covers (for example: "Items bought from Nov 1 to Dec 31, 2026 can be returned until Jan 31, 2027.").
- "Amazon gives me until Jan 31. Why don't you?" Explain your own window without criticizing anyone else's.
- "Can you waive the fee?" Spell out when agents may waive a fee (damaged or wrong item, for example) so the answer is consistent.
- "My gift arrived in the wrong size." Point gift recipients to the exchange route and explain how to return without the buyer's order details, if your portal supports it.
For a full checklist of peak-season preparation, get our free peak-season readiness checklist.
FAQ
What percentage of merchants charge return fees?
In Loop's vendor-reported 2026 benchmark of more than 4,000 Shopify merchants (returns from Nov 1, 2024 to Oct 31, 2025), 65.2% charged a return fee on at least some outcomes.
What is the average return fee?
Loop reports an average fee of $9.04 charged to shoppers on returns, normalized to US dollars (vendor-reported).
Do shoppers think return fees are fair?
Most don't. Three-quarters of adults in Morning Consult's 2026 holiday survey said return fees are unreasonable.
What is Amazon's 2026 holiday return deadline?
Items bought on Amazon.com from Nov 1 to Dec 31, 2026 can be returned until Jan 31, 2027 (Apple products until Jan 15, 2027). Amazon told sellers the policy will apply every year.
What is TikTok Shop's 2026 holiday return deadline?
TikTok Shop says US items sold from Nov 11 (4 p.m. PT) to Dec 31, 2026 can be returned until Feb 10, 2027, overriding a seller's own return window. Some categories, such as electronics and jewelry, may keep their standard rules, and auction orders aren't eligible.
How much of holiday sales do retailers expect to be returned?
In NRF and Happy Returns' 2025 report, retailers expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned.
Sources
All checked 2026-10-28.
- Loop, "Retention Benchmarks of High-Performing Brands" (2026 Global Ecommerce Report; vendor report, Loop merchant data Nov 1, 2024–Oct 31, 2025): https://www.loopreturns.com/reports/retention-benchmarks-2026/
- NRF and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape, Oct 15, 2025: https://nrf.com/research/2025-retail-returns-landscape
- NRF, "Consumers Expected to Return Nearly $850 Billion in Merchandise in 2025," Oct 15, 2025: https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/consumers-expected-to-return-nearly-850-billion-in-merchandise-in-2025
- Morning Consult, "2026 Holiday Season Retail Trends": https://morningconsult.com/reports/2026-holiday-season-retail-trends
- Amazon, News_Amazon, "Extended return window for items bought in November and December 2026," Seller Central Seller Forums announcement, Oct 15, 2026: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/seller-forums/discussions/t/fcc4e6f3-5e86-4b04-be84-82f9bcc2558a
- PPC Land, Luis Rijo, "Amazon makes its January 31 holiday return deadline an annual rule," Oct 20, 2026 (analysis of Amazon's Seller News post): https://ppc.land/amazon-makes-its-january-31-holiday-return-deadline-an-annual-rule/
- MediaPost, "All They Want For Christmas Is A Price They Can Afford" (Research Intelligencer; secondary report on Morning Consult's survey, which it calls Trends in Retail: Fall Holiday Season 2026): https://www.mediapost.com/research/1458/all-they-want-for-christmas-is-a-price-they-can-afford/
- Amazon, News_Amazon, customized FBA return grading criteria, Seller Central Seller Forums announcement, Oct 19, 2026 (checked 2026-10-28): https://sellercentral.amazon.com/seller-forums/discussions/t/731e6e69-5bfa-4a4f-9685-acb9da76153b
- Shopify Changelog, "Tax is now calculated on return shipping fees," Sep 25, 2026 (checked 2026-10-28): https://changelog.shopify.com/posts/tax-is-now-calculated-on-return-shipping-fees
- Shopify Changelog, "Return window overrides now available," Sep 29, 2026 (checked 2026-10-28): https://changelog.shopify.com/posts/return-window-overrides-now-available
- TikTok Shop Seller University (US), after-sales policy, dated Oct 21, 2026 (checked 2026-10-28): https://seller-us.tiktok.com/university/essay?knowledge_id=3253210454181634&lang=en
- TikTok Shop Seller University (US), "2026 Black Friday & Cyber Monday (BFCM) Seller Campaign Guide," dated Oct 19, 2026 (checked 2026-10-28): https://seller-us.tiktok.com/university/essay?knowledge_id=26854147802894&lang=en
- PageSpeed Matters, "Return Fee Statistics 2026: 40.8% of Shopify Stores Charge," Oct 19, 2026 (agency study; phrase-pattern reading of 4,908 refund policies; checked 2026-10-28): https://www.pagespeedmatters.com/resources/data-studies/return-fee-statistics
- Blue Yonder, "2026 Consumer Retail Returns Survey: Nearly half of Americans who shop with AI have returned a recommended item" (vendor survey, fielded September 2026, more than 5,000 consumers in five countries incl. 2,000 in the US; date not shown; checked 2026-10-28): https://edge.sitecorecloud.io/blueyonderie8e6-corporateefb0-prod6ccb-be06/media/project/blueyonder/corporate/files/resources/nearly-half-of-americans-have-returned-an-ai-recommended-item.pdf
- Blue Yonder, Mckenna Bailey, "What the 2026 Consumer Retail Returns Survey reveals about supply chain efficiency," Oct 27, 2026 (vendor blog; checked 2026-10-28): https://blueyonder.com/blog/2026/what-the-consumer-retail-returns-survey-reveals-about-supply-chain-efficiency
- EU Retail Platform, "Share of online retailers offering free returns rises to 61% in Germany, Austria and Switzerland," Oct 8, 2026 (survey of 108 online retailers; surveying organisation not named; checked 2026-10-28): https://transition-pathways.europa.eu/retail/news/share-online-retailers-offering-free-returns-rises-61-germany-austria-and-switzerland